Am I bigfooting right?

Couldn't tell you if you're doing it correctly on pally or not but I think the person who said that to you is the sad one lol..
Why bother telling someone they're doing a "terrible" job only to then leave them instead of giving them advice or show them how much better you can do it zzz
I like your NX look by the way

 

He’s right that how you actually suppose to do BF

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=702BU6AWKDs

 

The video shows in every 3 attacks you missed 1.
Try use a claymore and record it again?

If you don't SPAM attack, you can make every attack hit even using stonetooth.
But it requires more focus and technique.

Claymore may still be the easiest way to go, especially if it's ATT is higher than your stonetooth.

 

I recomend you to use a claymore instead of a stonetooth, because the fast weapons misses on the iframes, it will be better for you i guess.

 

so what? try 1v1 once,it’s really fun

 

Looks fine to me. Maybe he was talking about you using ST rather than a claymore.

Also I usually pin on the right rather than the left, just a preference. Idk if it changes anything

 

I want to see a video of you doing it with claymore. I'm pretty sure you are suppose to be able to get 100% of your hits in with claymore.

 

From this video, I think you should attack it twice, wait it face the wall, then attack again.
Stonetooth or Claymore doesn't matter.

 

this vid is with normal speed 2h sword and booster. dont know about stonetooth

 

i dont spam it its all timing and positioning

 

Just do what your want to do, keep your personal thought without disturbing.