ANIME

I love Trigger's stuff! If you liked the action and high energy of the other anime you've watched, try Kill la Kill, Darling in the Franxx, or SSSS Gridman. Little Witch Academia is a classic from them, but it's also a bit cutesy and your list is very shonen heavy so idk if you'd like that haha.
If you liked the story and pace of YLIA, try some of Kyoto Animation's works. Violet Evergarden might be a nice place to start if you liked YLIA.

cheers!

 

One Piece

 

That is a LOT for one year!
Possibly more than I've seen.
A few lesser known or less 'Shounen' and fantasy than the ones you listed:

-Clannad: It's pretty much a love story, but I've noticed a lot of people that normally wouldn't look twice at the romance genre have liked it. Also, make sure you have tissues when you start watching.

-Kotoura-san: Also a love story XD between a girl who can read minds and a pervert.

-The Lost Village: I'm not even sure how to explain this one. Psychological thriller?

-Hetalia! Cutesy and light, 5 minute episodes of countries as people. No strong emphasis on historical accuracy, just comedy and fun.
(Good for when you have to wait an indeterminate amount of time)

Oh, and Log Horizon! Which IS Shounen and fantasy and unfortunately overshadowed by SAO but pretty different and very good.

 

• Mysterious Girlfriend X: A great anime revolving around a very weird concept. It's a romantic story about two lovers, Urabe and Tsubaki. They are not your average couple though, they don't do the usual habit of kissing and hugging each other, instead they swap each other's drool. At first that seems like a very weird anime to get into, but as you watch the show makes all the weirdness about itself feel normal and as a result you get an anime that is very genuine of itself. Would recommend if you're into romance animes. Would not recommend if you cringe about the drool thing (but give it a try!!).
• Spice And Wolf: I haven't watched this one in a while so my memory might be vague, but it's a romantic anime about a trader and a wolf girl who travel the land together and encounter a series of difficulties on their journey. The show never got concluded though, so if you want to know what happens after the second season you'll need to pick up on the light novels.
• Serial Experiments Lain: An anime in which the border between the real world and 'The Wired' starts to crumble. As Lain, the main character, gets interested in computer technology, she discovers that reality is not what it seems to be. Great anime if you like a good mystery, although most of the questions that spring up from the anime, you will have to answer yourself.
• Gakkougurashi: Great anime, but i don't wanna spoil anything, so i'll keep it at that.
• Perfect Blue: A psychological horror movie about a former J-pop idol moving on to become an actor. I also don't want to spoil anything about this one.
• Anohana: A real tearjerker of an anime. The story is a very heartwarming and welcoming one about a group of friends all grown up, but the ending can make even the toughest among us cry.
• Tokyo Godfathers: A nice little comedy movie about three homeless people raising a child they found abandoned in the streets.
• Flying Witch: Just a very cozy anime to sit through. Recommended to watch this alongside an anime you know is hard to get through.

Those are just some of my favorites among the years i've watched anime (5 years iirc, 375 hours of anime).
I'd say for one year though, you've really watched a lot of anime.

 

Jojo

And start from part 1

 

Colorful (カラフル): A 2010 Japanese animated feature film directed by Keiichi Hara. It is based on the novel of the same name written by Eto Mori, produced by Sunrise and animated by the animation studio Ascension. It also deals with some of the pressures on school children as they come up to graduation before entering college or university.

Spoiler: Warning

Deals with suicide, cheating, stress, death, jealousy,depression and also about life

 

If you enjoy musical animes.
Nodame Cantabile, K-ON, Kimi no Uso, & Love Live are some suggestions i have for ya.

 

Me watching Neon Genesis Evangelion for the first time

 

I'll post some links for their synopsis so that you can take a look and check them out yourself, listed by my personal favorites.

*Some have extended series continued by viewing one of the main characters and you'll find a list of them under 'Animeography'.

Series
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - Gou (Higurashi: When They Cry - Gou) *
Gakkou no Kaidan (Ghost Stories)
Gleiphir
Mahou Shoujo Site (Magical Girl Site)
Ousama Game The Animation (King's Game)
Mousou Dairinin (Paranoia Agent)
Blood+
Blood-C *
Durarara!! *
Occultic;Nine
Mayoiga (The Lost Village)
Ajin (Ajin: Demi-Human) *
Death Note / Death Note: Rewrite
Mirai Nikki (Future Diary) / Mirai Nikki: Redial
Zombieland Saga *
Shingeki no Kyojin (Attack on Titan) *

Movies
Mind Game
Tenki no Ko (Weathering with You) *(Your Name - Taki x Mitsuha / Natori x Tessie(cameo)
Toki no Kakeru Shoujo (The Girl Who Leapt Through Time)
Summer Wars

Well, have fun with whatever you choose.
yes most are horror/thrillers.

 

Konosuba!

Probably the only isekai I like tbh. Dude gets reincarnated into a fantasy world but he learns his "OP party members" are all useless.
There are two seasons and a movie.
Got renewed for a third season recently and that airs in the coming months.

 

Started season 2 today!

 

Oh yeah a friend told me to watch it. Seen the first episode and was like...i dont know man this doesnt seem like anything i really want to watch but he told me just please watch it. I have a Three episode rule for anime, if i dont get sucked in within three episodes ill drop it, and im glad i kept watching. Was def. Worth.