Add a Mano Spawn every 2~ hours on Maple Island.

I agree with this idea 100%.

 

How long would it take to kill Mano? If it's rather short, wouldn't this lead to islanders only focusing on killing Mano and nothing else, meaning that the islanders are only online when Mano spawns? How big of a problem would that be?

I'm not part of the islanding community so I wouldn't know the answers to this lmao but I thought it might be nice to dicuss lol bye

 

People are always suggesting let's add X to Maple Island. Let's give beginners special items and treatment. Let's bend over backwards and make all the events dull so that even islanders can participate in them.

The thing is, regardless of if it's GMS-like or purist vanilla, islanders are islanders for a reason. The main focus of being an islander is to restrict your content. Maple Island is Maple Island, a brief intro designed for low level players to learn the basics, level up quickly, and then leave.

If we start adding Mano, where does it end? I'm not really a fan of slippery slope arguments myself, but in this case it's a special circumstance. I think Maple Island should be left exactly as is because it's specifically designed to be someplace you are supposed to leave, not camp out and train and one day take on a boss. If you want to do that, leave maple island and level up your beginner as normal.

 

I completely support Lionheart's opinion.
I think that islanders have already had plenty of new event items that GMS didn't provide in V62 such as: Super Snowboard (although it's limited), Valentine Rose and Lunch Box.
There would be probably more that I don't know of since I recently made an islander.

Why do people choose to be an islander?
People knew and accepted that they would have limited features for being an islander.
What else would islanders need after Mano?
More new weapons to use rare scrolls?

I'm not being negative or sarcastic to OP, but Maple Island should remain as same as now in my honest opinion.
I know some of islanders may hate my comment according to poll, but everyone has the right to express one's own thought.

 

Tbh, I tend to side with the argument that Maple Island should be left alone. Since MapleLegends is advertised as a very GMS-like server, once custom monsters/items/etc. starts being added to benefit Islanders, or whomever it may be, it begins to lose that likeness to GMS, and may turn future players off.

However, maybe more events geared towards Islanders would be a good alternative?

 

I do not have an islander and probablly never will but if the majority of islanders do in fact like this idea and is nothing too crazy why turn it down? It is literally their own world and do not affect anything outside maple island (such thing as adding a late game goal for islanders). Maybe the drops or exp would be a matter or arguing but if the idea is just to have something big to kill just for fun, I really don't see the point why not adding this. For me this is a matter of numbers, how many islanders are there and how many would like something like this being added... but it should most likekly depend on them rather than non islanders.

That is true but please correct me if I'm wrong but don't we already did that with end-game content that is not v62 but we do have in legends? And if the majority of islanders right now do like this manon feature for example, it is most likekly that future players (future islanders) also like the idea

 

Mano are the boss of snails, adding it Maple Island is appropriate, removing any drops which you think might be island-breaking. Talking about exp, grinding normally gives more exp than killing mano, so it isn't a problem.

 

The majority of islanders want this? That's news to me. I actually know there's many islanders that don't want Maple Island touched.

But who does this affect? It doesn't just affect islanders. It affects everyone, since all players begin their journey on Maple Island. And even some players that don't intend to stay still like to explore.

The problem I think is that if this server wants to advertise itself as nostalgic (even though it's technically not true with all the additional features) it really breaks that promise if we find all kinds of new stuff on Maple Island. In late game I can perfectly understand, since there's only so much content and players need something to work towards.

And also, having super islanders kind of defeats the purpose of Maple Island. Another reason it exists is to separate the completely new players from older players, so they don't get bullied. So what happens when we make Maple Island more appealing and add all kinds of new stuff to it? It's no longer nostalgic, and then it introduces new risk of high level players bullying low level players.

 

How do you know that? Anyone can vote in these polls, not just islanders.

My reaction isn't "over the top" just because I disagree with you. I believe Maple Island should be untouched. Completely.

How much change is too much change? Apparently you think a little change is ok. Fair enough, that's your opinion, but don't attack me because I disagree. Think of it like this:

How much smoking is too much smoking? Maybe in this instance, you'd be a guy saying it's ok for people to have a cigarette once a week. As for me, I'd firmly say zero, never, ever.

 

Well before anyone roasts Land on "Island tradition"...since when did we the island get Super Snowboards...or Golden Surfboards for that matter?
I definitely see both sides, I would like the island to be %100 GMS-like, but thats not the reality..so adding Mano isn't the craziest idea.

 

I'm not as high level as the other people posting here but I honestly think that this would be a positive edition to the island.

 

No thank you, its about time mapleisland got a bit more quiet again.

 

I didn't read all of the replies but I think Maple Island should be... just Maple Island (Lionheart and CHANEL already said). That's honestly the choice you make by staying there. Seems to be what islanding is about to me.

I actually disagree here. On most part the items that are on Maple Island now were also available back in the old days. Maple weapons and roses did drop from monsters if I recall correctly. There have been a few additions but that's mostly because in the end, the island isn't the main priority of events - as it shouldn't be.

Adding that boss would actually change the playing field. It brings a whole slew of scrolls (which will be far more powerful than the new weapons introduced by events - cause the scrolls have no level limit). It will also make farming scrolls way more easily.

In general suggestions to add new content to Maple Island feel a lot like "we got A, so now we want B". It's never going to be enough and in my opinion it's against the spirit of islanding.

 

One of the most civilized answers here. You openly admit opposition, but stay open-minded. A much better response than people who don't even island and think that just because it goes against what they think, that's the way it should be, even though it had literally 0 effect on them.

Edit: Also, in my opinion, if you are using the purity argument, it should apply to the whole server. Is NX free in GMS? No. are the rates 2/1/1/3 in GMS? Nah, they are 1/1/1/1. This is a private server, if you can't get over the fact that there are going to be some differences, maybe you shouldn't play it.

 

As an islander I think it would be fun to add something like this. 99% of the community would honestly never even see this so I don't see why not.

 

You are an islander, your voice should be heard on this.