Warrior [Guide] Hyoon's Comprehensive Sword Comparison

Guildline:
- Hero's in calculations are level 200
- All armour except gloves are perfect 70%
- All weapons are perfect 10%

I wanted to make a sword comparison guide that would be suitable for MapleLegend's limitations. I got the idea from here.

Spoiler: Items Used

Helmet - 17 STR, 37 DEX
Face - 7 DEX
Earrings - 10 DEX
Necklace - 23 STR, 23 DEX
Top - 21 STR, 3 DEX
Bottom - 18 DEX
Cape - 10 Attack
Shoes - 2 Attack 7 DEX
Gloves - 21 Attack
Red Katana - 123 Attack, 21 STR
Carabella - 145 Attack, 21 STR
Stonetooth - 141 Attack, 21 STR
Shield - 20 Attack, 10 STR

Spoiler: Red Katana Calculations

Stats with MW 20

Base STR = 999*1.1 = 1098
Base DEX = 23*1.1 = 25

Total STR = 1190
Total DEX = 130
Total Clean Attack = 176

Stats with multiplier
(1190*4) + 130 = 4890
4890/100 = 48.9

Cider

48.9*196 = 9584
9584*1.04 = 9967 (Echo)

9967*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 78,779
78,779/0.63 = 125,046 DPS (~ 7.5m DPM)

HeartStopper

48.9*236 = 11540
11540*1.04 = 12001 (Echo)

12001*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 94,855
94,855/0.63 = 150,563 DPS (~ 9m DPM)

Onyx Apple

48.9*276 = 13496
13496*1.04 = 14035 (Echo)

14035*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 110,932
110,932/0.63 = 176,082 DPS (~ 10.5m DPM)

Spoiler: Carabella Calculations

Stats with MW 20

Base STR = 999*1.1 = 1098
Base DEX = 23*1.1 = 25

Total STR = 1190
Total DEX = 130
Total Clean Attack = 198

Stats with multiplier
(1190*4) + 130 = 4890
4890/100 = 48.9

Cider

48.9*218 = 10660
10660*1.04 = 11086 (Echo)

11086*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 87,623
87,623/0.69 = 126,989 DPS (~ 7.6m DPM) (Without SI)
87,623/0.63 = 139,084 DPS (~ 8.3m DPM) (With SI)

HeartStopper

48.9*258 = 12616
12616*1.04 = 13120 (Echo)

13120*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 103,700
103,700/0.69 = 150,289 DPS (~ 9m DPM) (Without SI)
103,700/0.63 = 164,603 DPS (~ 9.8m DPM) (With SI)
Onyx Apple

48.9*298 = 14572
14572*1.04 = 15154 (Echo)

15154*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 119,777
119,777/0.69 = 173,589 DPS (~ 10.4m DPM) (Without SI)
119,777/0.63 = 190,122 DPS (~ 11.4m DPM) (With SI)

Spoiler: Stonetooth Calculations

Stats with MW 20

Base STR = 999*1.1 = 1098
Base DEX = 23*1.1 = 25

Total STR = 1180
Total DEX = 130
Total Clean Attack = 174

Stats with multiplier
(1180*4.6) + 130 = 5558
5558/100 = 55.58

Cider

55.58*194 = 10782
10782*1.04 = 11213 (Echo)

11213*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 88,627
88,627/0.69 = 128,444 DPS (~ 7.7m DPM) (Without SI)
88,627/0.63 = 140,677 DPS (~ 8.4m DPM) (With SI)

HeartStopper

55.58*234 = 13005
13005*1.04 = 13525 (Echo)

13525*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 106,901
106,901/0.69 = 154,928 DPS (~ 9.3m DPM) (Without SI)
106,901/0.63 = 169,684 DPS (~ 10.2m DPM) (With SI)
Onyx Apple

55.58*274 = 15228
15228*1.04 = 15837 (Echo)

15837*5.2 (Brandish)*1.9 (Advanced Combo Attack)*0.8 (Sword Mastery) = 125,175
125,175/0.69 = 181,413 DPS (~ 10.8m DPM) (Without SI)
125,175/0.63 = 192,341 DPS (~ 11.5m DPM) (With SI)

Spoiler: Side by Side Comparison

Cider

Red Katana -
125,046 DPS (~ 7.5m DPM)
Carabella -
126,989 DPS (~ 7.6m DPM) (Without SI)
139,084 DPS (~ 8.3m DPM) (With SI)
Stonetooth -
128,444 DPS (~ 7.7m DPM) (Without SI)
140,677 DPS (~ 8.4m DPM) (With SI)

HeartStopper

Red Katana -
150,563 DPS (~ 9m DPM)
Carabella -
150,289 DPS (~ 9m DPM) (Without SI)
164,603 DPS (~ 9.8m DPM) (With SI)
Stonetooth -
154,928 DPS (~ 9.3m DPM) (Without SI)
169,684 DPS (~ 10.2m DPM) (With SI)

Onyx Apple

Red Katana -
176,082 DPS (~ 10.5m DPM)
Carabella -
173,589 DPS (~ 10.4m DPM) (Without SI)
190,122 DPS (~ 11.4m DPM) (With SI)
Stonetooth -
181,413 DPS (~ 10.8m DPM) (Without SI)
192,341 DPS (~ 11.5m DPM) (With SI)

Spoiler: TL;DR

Stonetooth wins in every aspect,
Heartstopper gives Stonetooth the greatest DPM difference,
Without SI, Red Katana starts beating Carabella at Heartstoppers
With SI, Red Katana does the least DPM at all attack pot ranges

Spoiler: Additional Calculations

Red Katana

DPS per additional Attack
176,082 (Onyx Apples DPS) - 150,563 (Heartstopper DPS) = 25,519
25,519/40 (Attack Difference) = 637.975 (DPS per Attack)

Difference @ Cider

Carabella No SI
126,989-125,046 = 1,943
1,943/637.975 = 3.04 (About 3 attack)
Carabella SI
139,084-125,046 = 14,038
14,038/637.975 = 22.003 (About 22 attack)

Stonetooth NO SI
128,444-125,046 = 3,398
3,398/637.975 = 5.326 (About 6 Attack)
Stonetooth SI
140,677-125,046 = 15,634
15,634/637.975 = 24.5 (About 25 Attack)

Difference @ HeartStopper

Carabella No SI
150,289-150,563 = -274
Already Reached
Carabella SI
164,603-150,563 = 14,040
14,040/637.975 = 22.007 (About 22 Attack)

Stonetooth No SI
154,928-150,563 = 4,365
4,365/637.975 = 6.841 (About 7 Attack)
Stonetooth SI
169,684-150563 = 19,121
19,121/637.975 = 29.97 (About 30 Attack)

Difference @ Onyx Apple

Carabella No SI
173,589-176,082 = 2,493
Already Reached
Carabella SI
190,122-176,082 = 14,040
14,040/637.975 = 22.007 (About 22 Attack)

Stonetooth No SI
181,413-176,082 = 5,331
5,331/637.975 = 8.35 (About 9 Attack)
Stonetooth SI
192,341-176,082 = 16,259
16,259/637.975 = 25.48 (About 26 Attack)

Credits:
https://mapleroyals.com/forum/threads/sword-comparisons.20163/
For the guideline and extensive formulas.