Warrior Analyze end-game WARRIOR bossing dpm of current meta

I'm not 100% sure of hero/dk parts. Please correct me if there is any wrong.
This analysis is a combination of theory and reality.
---
Last Update : 2021-5-20
the number about hero with SE is wrong.
I'll update in the future.
---
2021-4-4 Analyze warrior bossing dpm of current meta
Spreadsheets
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1CDWItO4ixQ0UNzn-0FmXiqC7TEdlXsnGn4_yOkmoNj4/edit?usp=sharing
---
All the data (weapon, equips, skills) are in the spreadsheets.
+7 claymore / +7 sky ski / 21wa gloves / 14wa cape / 10wa MoN
---
element neutral
(HT, zak, JC, papu, ravana, verga/b3, griffey, levi, lyka, dodo, dunas, toad)
Let's check the dpm in theory first.

pally dpm = 1.056x hero dpm
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

pally use blast/holy to 1 target
pally use ACB/holy to 2 targets
hero use brandish
dk use spear crusher
hero mix 2mins rage + 4mins enrage(26wa buff)
---
2 targets dpm is used for calculate HT right side dpm from theory to reality.

pally dpm = 0.631x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.585x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

But seldom of bosses are 2 targets.
Maybe,
(1)zak arms
(2)JC between 1st and 2nd summon
(3)HT wing+arm
---
Question : You may ask, why there is no "3 targets dpm" ?
Answer : There is rarely of boss in MapleLegends contain 3 targets for paladin to use acb/holy.
All i know is zak arms or JC between 2nd and 3rd summon, but those dpm are ignorable.
There is no point in discussing them.
---
horntail
In reality.
Let's simplify to focus on heads dpm. Ignore the arm/wing.
---
horntail left side

pally dpm = 0.704x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.421x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

pally use blast/holy
hero use brandish
dk use spear crusher

1.While both heads are up (chance=4/9)
pally stand at middle platform
hero/dk stand at middle platform

pally 75% of time hit left head
pally 25% of time hit mid head
hero/dk 75% of time hit left head + 25% of time hit air (left head duck)
hero/dk 100% of time hit mid head

2.While left head weapon cancel, mid head is up (chance=2/9)
pally stand at top platform
hero/dk stand at middle platform

pally 0% of time hit left head
pally 75% of time hit mid head + 25% of time hit air (mid head duck)
hero/dk 0% of time hit left head (left head cancel)
hero/dk 75% of time hit mid head + 25% of time hit air (mid head duck)

3.While mid head weapon cancel, left head is up (chance=2/9)
pally stand at bottom platform
hero/dk stand at middle/bottom platform

pally 75% of time hit left head + 25% of time hit air (left head duck)
pally 0% of time hit mid head
hero/dk 75% of time hit left head + 25% of time hit air (left head duck)
hero/dk 0% of time hit mid head (mid head cancel)

4.While both heads weapon cancel (chance=1/9)
pally 0% of time hit head
hero/dk 0% of time hit head

5.
pally dpm = blast/holy x0.778
hero/dk dpm = 1 target x1.167

*More details in the spreadsheets page "analyze".
---
horntail right side

pally dpm = 0.763x hero dpm (100% will be lower than this)
(hero dpm = 1.311x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

pally use ACB/holy while both heads are up
pally use blast/holy while both heads are up but right head duck
pally use blast/holy while 1 of heads is weapon cancel
hero use brandish
dk use spear crusher

1.While both heads are up (chance=4/9)
pally stand at bottom platform
hero/dk stand at bottom platform
pally use mix blast/acb/holy

pally 75% of time hit both heads with ACB/holy
pally 25% of time hit mid head with blast/holy
hero/dk 75% of time hit right head + 25% of time hit air (right head duck)
hero/dk 100% of time hit mid head

2.While right head weapon cancel, mid head is up (chance=2/9)
pally stand at top platform
hero/dk stand at top platform (maybe there is some better option eg. wing/arm)
pally use blast/holy

pally 0% of time hit right head
pally 75% of time hit mid head + 25% of time hit air (mid head duck)
hero/dk 0% of time hit right head
hero/dk 75% of time hit mid head + 25% of time hit air (mid head duck)

3.While mid head weapon cancel, right head is up (chance=2/9)
pally stand at bottom platform
hero/dk stand at bottom platform
pally use blast/holy

pally 75% of time hit right head (right head duck)
pally 25% of time hit mid head (mid head cancel)
hero/dk 75% of time hit right head + 25% of time hit air (right head duck)
hero/dk 100% of time hit mid head (mid head cancel)

4.While both heads weapon cancel (chance=1/9)
pally 0% of time hit head
hero/dk 0% of time hit head

5.
pally dpm = ACB/holy x0.667 + blast/holy x0.444
hero/dk dpm = 1 target x1.167

*If pally mix ACB/blast at right side
This is good in theory, but bad at practice.
Since skills of right head animation are too fast, pally is hitting air if right head duck.
And in reality, pally usually will be ACB on the air.
pally dpm = 0.763x hero dpm (100% will be lower than this)
(hero dpm = 1.311x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

*If pally pure blast at right side
This is actually what pally would do.
The pally right side dpm is similar to left side.
pally dpm = 0.704x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.421x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

*More details in the spreadsheets page "analyze".

3.Data source
AioriaX Making parts of Horntail elementally-weak (link)
BananaPie Increase vertical hitbox for mid head in Horntail (link)

---
cwkpq
In reality.

1.When the cleave's 3 bosses are up
pally use ACB/fire
rellik is weak to fire

pally dpm = 0.696x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.437x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

2.After rellik die, hsalf+red nirg are up
pally use ACB/fire
hsalf+red nirg are neutral

pally dpm = 0.597x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.676x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

3.After red nirg die, hsalf is up
pally use blast/ice
dpm is same as targa
(the targa chart dpm x2 for all warriors)
pally dpm = 1.070x hero dpm
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm
---
scar
(scar, verga/b2, pianus, bigfoot)
In reality.
Consider scar 50% of time weapon cancel.
pally use blast/fire
scar weak to fire

pally dpm = 1.487x hero dpm
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm
---
targa
(targa, krexel/b1, manon, hsalf)
In reality.
Consider targa 50% of time weapon cancel.
pally use blast/ice
targa weak to ice

pally dpm = 1.070x hero dpm
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm
---
scar+targa
In reality.
Consider scar 50% of time weapon cancel.
Consider targa 50% of time weapon cancel.
There are 3 methods for pally to do scarga.

1.pally blast/fire + blast/ice
pally dpm = (blast/fire + blast/ice) x0.375
hero/dk dpm = 1 target x1
pally dpm = 0.959x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.043x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

2.pally mix blast/fire + ACB/ice + blast/ice + ACB/fire
pally dpm = (blast/fire + blast/ice) x0.25 + (ACB/ice + ACB/fire) x0.125
hero/dk dpm = 1 target x1
pally dpm = 0.831x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.203x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

3.pally afk blast/fire + blast/ice
pally dpm = (blast/fire + blast/ice) x0.25
hero/dk dpm = 1 target x1
pally dpm = 0.639x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.564x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm

Pally afk blast on scar or targa which summoned earlier.
Whether it is in weapon cancel or not.
It happens when range attackers in party are HPless.
Kill scarga safely.
---
krexel right eye
(krexel/b2, morgana, ergoth(GuildPQ))
pally use blast without element charge
The bosses are strong to holy/fire/lightning/ice.

pally dpm = 0.571x hero dpm
(hero dpm = 1.752x pally dpm)
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm
---
1 thread can only upload 10 files, so the other pics are at below reply.
---
Not to mention that if the pally use Crushed Skull + Shield, their dpm will be lower than Claymore and decrease by alots with apple.

To check more paladin dpm in different weapon, please click the link below
Paladin damage comparison 20wa shield (link)
---

 

---
nameless
(verga/b1, nibergen, nameless, headless horseman, lilynouch, crow)
pally use blast/lightning
nameless weak to lightning

pally dpm = 1.284x hero dpm
dk dpm = 0.938x hero dpm
---

 

Would you agree that I just do (blast/fire + blast/ice)/2 as an average dpm?
I assumed it's like half of the time blast scar and half of the time blast targa within the whole run.
It might close to be it, if there are many attackers + 1 pally.

idk hero/dk can or cannot hit mid+right head.
I assumed they can.
I'm sure with paladin ACB and blast can hit mid+right head at the right side.
(1h sword ACB horizontal range is very very tiny. I can hit mid+right head with ACB by standing at the very edge of (right top)bottom platform.)

 

We're saying the same thing.
But the difference is :
When I run scarga as a pally, I didn't do ACB/ice while scar weapon cancel.
I choose to rush the scar abit away from targa.
Then blast/ice the targa.
This is one of the reason why I do (blast/fire+blast/ice)/2 as an average dpm.
Another reason is the summon order issue, it makes sure I can always blast 1 of scar/targa which is earlier summoned.
ACB/ice will instead lose some dpm.
At the same time, range attacker can go to top platform to hit the targa.

 

Counting arm/wing dmg will make the pally dpm look extremely low but you're RIGHT.
I didn't count them because idk about hero cleaving arm/wing.
Is it 100% of time hitting right head + wing + right arm?
Can hero hit right arm 100% of time while it cast every skill?
I'm willing to hear Hero/Dk sharing your idea.
Thanks!

 

I re-adjusted the SCAR / TARGA / SCARGA 3 charts few mins ago.
Weapon cancel is now considered.
The weapon cancel should be calculated when we talk about weapon cancel with blast/acb and mechanism of summoned layer.
It is closer to reality right now.

Off Topic :
Pally's skill Threaten description is kinda misleading.
"Use MP to temporarily threaten a monster. Decreases the level of weapon attack and weapon defense of every monster around the area."

I tested threaten on Horntail main body, threaten only affect 6 targets.

After HT body summoned.
6 targets in HT body are leg, tail, wing, left arm, right arm, right head.
Left head and mid head aren't affected.

After leg and tail died.
6 targets in HT are wing, left arm, right arm, right head, left head, mid head.

It is some sort of summon layer mechanism.
This is why pally hit the left head rather than mid head.
This is why pally hit the right head rather than mid head.
This is why pally hit the wing rather than left arm or right arm.
This is why pally hit the zak/scar/targa b2 summon rather than zak/scar/targa b3.

So the summon layer is like :
(tail, leg, wing) >> (left arm, right arm) >> right head >> left head >> mid head
, from early to lately.

It also happened in zak arm.
I cannot threaten all of 8 arms because threaten only affect 6 targets max.